The Missing Exhibition: Building Aquí

Behind the Scenes of the “Aquí en Chicago” Exhibition

When students at a predominantly Latino/a/e alternative high school in Chicago (Instituto Justice and Leadership Academy) realized that Chicago’s major history museum had no information about the Latino/a/e third of the city in its permanent exhibition, they took a stand—and made history. The Missing Exhibition: Building Aquí is a 4-part podcast that follows the students’ protest, the exhibition it inspired, and the long, rich legacy of Latine resistance, migration, and culture in the city. Told through music, oral history, and the sounds of Chicago, the series features the work of legendary Chicano folklorist Chuy Negrete and the voices of curators, activists, and community members working to expand the archive.

From the Puerto Rican Young Lords’ transformation from street gang to political force fighting “urban renewal” and displacement in Lincoln Park, to Mexican American students pushing for bilingual education, and beyond—this podcast explores the profound ways Latino/a/e Chicagoans have shaped the city and why this important history is still missing from many institutions that should be preserving it.

Learn more about the podcast in a blog post by co-creators Elena Gonzales, Curator of Civic Engagement & Social Justice at CHM, and Jesse Betend, producer at Rivet360.

Listen on Spotify Listen on Apple Podcasts

Produced by Rivet360’s Jesse Betend in partnership with the Chicago History Museum.

Episode 1: The Missing Exhibition

When students from an alternative high school confront the Chicago History Museum over its lack of Latino/a/e representation, they set off a chain of events that leads to a historic new exhibition—and a reckoning with the past.

This episode also traces the life and legacy of Rudy Lozano, the activist whose name the students carry, and legendary folk artist Jesus “Chuy” Negrete, whose corridos have preserved history and honored the lives of countless Latine Chicagoans.

CHM_Aqui_PodcastGraphic_1400x1400_Graphic_2_3
Episode 1: The Missing Exhibition Transcript

JESSE BETEND: In 2019, a group of students from a high school on Chicago’s South Side took a field trip to the Chicago History Museum.   

ELENA GONZALES: It was a history and social studies class, and they toured Chicago: Crossroads of America, which is the central exhibition at the museum and has been on view now for almost 20 years.

BETEND: They were not impressed…

ANTON MIGLIETTA: They had hot dogs, they had ladies’ gowns, they had the Cubs and White Sox forever, and all this other stuff. But yet, nothing on, you know, on us, nothing on Latino history, Latinx history.

BETEND: The students who happened to be mostly Mexican, noticed quickly that the museum that was meant to represent their city, had completely failed to represent them.

MIGLIETTA: …So they’re all pissed at that, right? They’re definitely pissed at that and just feeling like that was bogus.

BETEND: So they decided to do something about it.

(Music)

BETEND: When a group of high school students confront the Chicago History Museum over its lack of representation, they set off a chain of events that leads to a historic new exhibition—and a reckoning with the past.

I’m Jesse Betend, and I’m partnering with the Chicago History Museum to unveil their new exhibition Aquí en Chicago.

Building Aqui is a 4-part podcast which follows the students’ protest, the exhibition that it inspired, and the rich legacy of Latine resistance and culture in the city—told through music, oral history, and the sounds of the city itself.

In this first episode we’ll meet Chicago History Museum Curator of Civic Engagement and Social Justice, Dr. Elena Gonzales, and explore the work of community historians like legendary folk artist Jesús “Chuy” Negrete, who are preserving history where institutions fail.

A student protest, a missing exhibition, and a labor leader whose legacy refuses to stay buried. This is the story of how a South Side classroom challenged a city’s narrative—and won.

(Music)

BETEND: The Chicago History Museum’s new exhibition, Aquí en Chicago, opens its doors on October 25th—but the story of how it came to be began nearly 6 years ago.

ELENA, SPEAKING TO MIGLIETTA: Can you take us back to 2019 and talk a little bit about what your class was like before your visit to the History Museum? (fades under narration)

BETEND: Dr. Elena Gonzales is the curator of Civic Engagement and Social Justice at the Chicago History Museum. She interviewed the class’s teacher, Anton Miglietta, for the museum’s oral history collection.

Back in 2019, Anton was “Mr. Miglietta,” teaching history and social studies at Instituto Justice and Leadership Academy.

MIGLIETTA: Rooted in Pilsen and Little Village communities in this area, also called Heart of Chicago.

BETEND: Reflecting the neighborhood around it, the school’s student body is nearly 40% Mexican.

The school is called Instituto Justice and Leadership Academy – one of two Chicago Public School charter schools under the parent organization Instituto del Progreso Latino. In 2017, the school, which was formally the Rudy Lozano Leadership Academy, named after a beloved Mexican labor organizer, was consolidated into IJLA. Though the school no longer bears Rudy’s name, the staff does aspire to carry on his social justice work through its student-led curriculum.

MIGLIETTA:  Being an alternative school model with the name Rudy Lozano Leadership Academy….  it just has this background of… social justice right from the beginning.

BETEND: Over his 20+ years in the classroom, Anton’s developed a habit. He likes to give his students a little survey to find out what topics most interest them. Some tend to come up again and again: immigration, community issues with police. Those are some of the big ones. But the results for the 2019 survey were surprising.

MIGLIETTA: so I asked them in the survey, what do you want more of? And they said, “field trips.” And so we said, okay, well what field trip should we do?

And a little list went up, and most of them said they had never been to the Chicago History Museum. And it was a Chicago history class. And so we kind of like, everybody looked at each other like, let’s do that one.

BETEND: So the day rolls around and our unusually eager highschoolers head downtown excited to see the history they’d been learning about in class.

GONZALES: They toured Chicago: Crossroads of America, which is the central exhibition at the museum and has been on view now for almost 20 years.

BETEND: A lot of classwork from the previous semester dealt with Indigenous history and the ways that institutions tended to portray communities of color. So the students were itching to put what they’d learned into practice and explore the museum through that specific lens.

GONZALES: Chicago: Crossroads of America is an exhibition that is 14,000 square feet. It’s the Museum’s central exhibition. It opened in 2006, and it really tells the story of Chicago as a metropolis, a city on the make, and a sort of business and transportation hub. It’s kind of an industrial history, and what I find is that it centers the city itself as a protagonist rather than the people.

BETEND: For anyone who hasn’t been, the museum’s premier exhibition Chicago: Crossroads of America, is all about BIG IDEAS and BIG SHOULDERS. Inside you’ll find an exhibition dedicated to each of our beloved baseball franchises, the Cubs and White Sox. Another section dedicated to the local titans of industry…

GONZALES: There are some pretty big displays on places like Crate & Barrel, Marshall Fields,

BETEND: …there was a special display dedicated to the Vienna hot dog.

(Music)

MIGLIETTA:  So they broke into groups of two or three. . . . In these groups of two or three they were all spread out, so I was just walking around, just sort of checking in with each group of two or three the best I could.

I remember at that time, a special exhibit was the women’s gowns. And they were checking that out and, and they, they were thinking about the sort of the classism of this, right? Or like, okay, “this is like rich, this looks like rich white women stuff, right?”

And then another group was looking at the exhibit at that time related to the Vienna hot dog and what have you. And they were like, okay, you know, they, they were like, “Okay, this is, you know, you know, just sort of popular food.” And then another group was looking at all the Cubs and White Sox stuff, and so as they were looking and observing these things and recognizing sort of the, um, sort of general and trivial Chicago history,

They then noticed, you know, some pieces on Indigenous history, not very well, you know, represented and, and not too authentic.

GONZALES: I think many people immediately notice the way in which this manifests in the very opening spaces of the Gallery. So if you go into Crossroads you experience a narrative that very much portrays Indigenous folks as being ancient history, gives them no agency. They do not have a voice, and furthermore the narrative states very specifically, and if I had the label in front of me, I would read it to you, but it states very specifically the ways in which the interactions between these groups positively affected colonizers and doesn’t really care at all about what happened to the indigenous folks in those interactions

MIGLIETTA: But then they really all noticed. Little group by little group. So it was really intriguing to see their individual responses.

BETEND: Most offensive was the exhibition’s treatment of the man widely recognized as the founder of Chicago. Jean Baptiste Point Dusable was an American trader, born in Haiti, who travelled all the way to modern day New Orleans where his ship was wrecked. Sometime around 1770, he would find himself near the mouth of the Chicago River, manning a trading post that would ultimately lay the foundation for the city of Chicago. Many Chicagoans take particular pride in the fact that Chicago’s symbolic father-figure, was a man we would today consider Latino, who wasn’t remotely “from here.”

MIGLIETTA: And you wouldn’t know. You’d have no idea.

It’s really like only about a foot and a half of an oval framed picture of DuSable with no real representation to who he was. No name above his plaque of significance. I think just below there’s a small piece. And you wouldn’t know. You’d have no idea. So they’re all pissed at that, right? They’re definitely pissed at that and just feeling like that was bogus.

A question came up of where’s stuff on Mexicans and other, you know, Latino groups, right? But, you know, most of them being Mexican, I think that’s, they’re like, “Where’s the Mexican?” Let’s go see. So they started to look for that.

And everyone was basically saying, “Yeah, I don’t see anything.” Right? Except for the Lowrider.

BETEND: As the students spread out again to explore “Crossroads” a second time, some of them start to rethink one of the first things they saw when they entered the museum.

GONZALES: In the front lobby of the museum at that time there was a beautiful Lowrider car, which really rubbed the students the wrong way given the lack of context. They didn’t really feel like their history was really being told and it was just this one car standing for the entirety of this third of Chicago

BETEND: Why was the Lowrider there like what was the thought process behind it and was something missed in communication?

GONZALES: Yes, I wanna start by saying that Chicago has a very vibrant and expressive and tight Lowrider community. There is the Slow and Low festival which is co-founded by Lauren M. Pacheco who’s one of our advisors on Aquí. The car, which is a 1978 Chevrolet Monte Carlo, was actually commissioned by the History Museum in 2006.

So there was this gentleman named Pedro Cisneros III who is from Bishop Texas, who came to Chicago in 2001 and formed this car club, Amistad Car Club. And you know he was building his community. He was connecting with likeminded individuals in Chicago, and they were making these beautiful cars, which have you know these incredible paint jobs, all these crazy tricks that they can do you know, they’re really works of art and they’re absolutely fantastic.

And the History Museum, like I said, commissioned the Monte Carlo in 2006 for the reopening of the newly expanded building, which is also the same time when Crossroads opened. At the time there was more context about the car club.

When the students encountered the car, there was not enough context about what it was even doing there and so the perception was, “We’re being stereotyped. The only thing the History Museum wants to say about Latine communities is that you know we drive these Lowriders.” And I can understand completely how the students got to this idea. I think it’s a disservice to the local Lowrider community to let it end there, because it’s not you know it’s not that Lowriders are bad, it’s not that that our Lowrider is bad, our Lowrider is fantastic and Lowriders are very cool.

BETEND: After the field trip was over Anton and the class walked to the lake to debrief.

MIGLIETTA:  That’s when the conversation started really spreading about, “I can’t believe there was nothing in there, you know?”

Um, ’cause that’s when they started talking about they had hot dogs, they had ladies gowns, they had the Cubs and White Sox forever and all this other stuff. But yet nothing, you know, like, like they didn’t even exist, you know? So we chopped that up and talked a little bit.

When we got back was when they were all queued in.

We’re sitting around in the classroom, they’re all queued in. And, Roger says, you know, “That’s, that’s bogus. I can’t believe that.” And I was like, “Well, what do y’all think? Like, what, what do you think you know you should do?,” and he said, “Let’s write a letter.” And I was like, “Oh, okay.” And, and a few people said, “No letter ain’t gonna do nothing.”

And a few people said, “Yeah, let’s do it.” And then another person said, “Or a petition”, and then another person said, “Nah, let’s do social media ’cause that’s more modern.”

So that’s when it got even more real, and Sammy really stepped up to provide a lot of the, um, um, always a very poignant comment, a very necessary one, a very, uh, process oriented also. So both content and process. Roger, he’s got a big teddy bear spirit right? But he’s just wanting to like, take action, right. But Sammy started to be real tactical about it

We essentially agreed that all these would be good tools. Let’s do the letter, a poster to bring the letter to life….

… And then let’s put those on social media and launch the petition. So it was like all of the above.

GONZALES:  So you knew from the beginning that you were gonna do all those different things?

MIGLIETTA: No, when I walked into debrief, I had no idea.

So they go through a little process of drafting and or forming a social media team. And Sammy was definitely on that with a few other people. Put together, uh, the first few social media posts, and they named the group,

Latinx History Now, I think something like that with the exclamation point. And then they, um, put up a few of their pictures with the posters. But anyway, before the museum even read the letters, they had already, it sounds like, got word of the social media posts.

And already responded back with some sort of, you know, effective, um, you know, whether it was PR approach or recognition or a little bit of both. Right. And then, yeah, conversation got sparked up pretty quickly after this social media, ’cause then they like invited us to converse with them, I think it was. And got us to set this day to meet with them

GONZALES:  And at that point, were the students surprised? Like now you are going to the History Museum to meet with the people there, that’s being set up. How was the response?

MIGLIETTA:  Most students were surprised that they got the response to the letters on social media. Um, most students were definitely surprised that it actually worked and worked so fast and that this was like actually happening.

Um, I think they thought they would have to protest more, or like, yeah.

BETEND: The day of the meeting arrives, and the students show up prepared. They’ve got their posters, they wrote a press release, they’ve even got a concrete list of demands.

GONZALES: I have them in front of me. They had a few different demands on their list. They wanted the CHM to issue an apology to Latine and generally to the youth of Chicago. They wanted us to create an advisory committee, and then they wanted that committee to have the power to determine what should happen to the Lowrider, and also they wanted an exhibition that asked for feedback and explained what the students were doing in their protest. They also wanted the museum to commit to rotating and permanent exhibition space for Latine history, and finally they hope to launch a city wide research curriculum development project. So kind of to make Anton has described this last demand as wanting to see a city wide movement around Latine history, and preparing teachers better for it making it more of a zeitgeist within our educational setting.

MIGLIETTA: And the press release was designed to get a little media there, so we didn’t have this meeting without documentation and without, you know, a public record of it.

So they sent out the press release and CBS Two News…  asked could they do an exclusive coverage of it, … So CBS2 News was there.

BETEND: The students carrying signs and posters, a collection of CHM staff including then Vice President of Interpretation and Education, Anton, their teacher, and a TV production crew all pile into the Museum’s front lobby… and past the infamous Lowrider…

MIGLIETTA: We get there, we get welcomed and brought up to the, uh, the old fancy room…

GONZALES: The Mandel Room.

MIGLIETTA: Yes.

GONZALES: For anyone listening in posterity.

MIGLIETTA: With the old fancy, um, you know, paintings of the old fancy white guys.

GONZALES: Mm-hmm.

MIGLIETTA: Um, so that was, you know, for, for the students that was just classic. That was just like, wow, this is, yeah, this is what they would have.

So the footage is so wonderful. ’Cause they’re just like these, you know, they’re, it’s on the news coverage, right?

GONZALES: They’re just straight up unvarnished.

MIGLIETTA: Yes. They really are. They really are. So it’s so, it’s so beautiful.

(CBS News Broadcast Audio)

REPORTER 1: They are pushing for answers and seeking some change.

CHM REPRESENTATIVE (PETER ALTER): I think what makes this day really special is to sit down and really dig into some of the issues that you raised.

REPORTER 2: CBS 2 was the only camera allowed inside a meeting between leaders of the Chicago History Museum and about 15 students from the Instituto Justice Leadership Academy.

STUDENT 1: This is a Chicago History Museum and we would like to see more of our people.

REPORTER 2: The alternative school is expressing their disappointment after noticing the exhibits and narratives about Latinx people fell short.

STUDENT 2: Imagine how many younger kids came in and didn’t think that their ethnicity or family background wasn’t as important because they didn’t see it in the museum.

MIGLIETTA: And then we started to hear from the museum officials, and they were both sort of like representing this, you know, apologetic energy as well as this is such an opportunity and thank you. And then I forgot the gentleman’s name.

GONZALES: Are we thinking about Peter Alter? Yeah. Yeah. So, Peter is one of the curators.

MIGLIETTA: Yeah. So, Peter comes out and addresses the, um, Lowrider and takes this, um, real humble approach of recognizing his role in it and like apologizing

ALTER: Our intention was not to offend, but that is a failure I would say that definitely lies specifically with me.

MIGLIETTA: So the students were, you know, thankful for that right afterwards, but they were really, you know, be a battle afterwards.

ALTER: We’ve got some work to do, hopefully through this process of meeting with you, you can help us think about what those next steps for the museum might be

(CBS interview)

REPORTER 2: And now they are getting results. A first step in what they hope will become a permanent or long running exhibit.

STUDENT 3: Well I am glad that questions are being answered and that we are coming into agreements

STUDENT 4: I am shocked because we actually got this far. I thought it wasn’t gonna go this way.

ALTER: And I hope that we can move forward in a collaborative way.

CBS REPORTER: Good for them for speaking up. Jim tells us that at the end of the meeting, the group picked another time to gather (fades into music)

BETEND: Do you have any insight into what the museum’s intentions were with meeting with the students were they prepared to meet these demands or was there some element of hoping to maybe find a compromise that didn’t require massive internal change?

GONZALES: I think that the museum wanted to hear the students out and see what they wanted and see how they could best come to an accord. The museum has a longstanding history of dealing with community based exhibitions as they come up and what that basically means is when a community makes enough noise about needing to be represented in Chicago history, the museum comes in and creates a temporary exhibition. And I know that’s uh stating things very bluntly but you know our Neighborhoods exhibitions are an example of that. So this I think was initially envisioned, I think initially the History Museum envisioned that the response to the students would be a community based temporary exhibition and that would happen relatively quickly.

BETEND: There was this moment where the head of negotiations for the museum pulls the teacher Anton aside.

MIGLIETTA: He brought me to the side two different times during this thing. So the first time was right after the meeting. Students, everybody’s in the room still, and he says, “We can do this really better with you, me, and, and you know, yourself, the principal, and, you know, and a few CHM representatives. We can just, you know, and we, you know, we might not really need the students, right?” And I said, “You know, that’s just not gonna happen.”

So I shared that with the students, right? ‘Cause I felt like they should know that, that, you know. They need to know they’re the ones organizing this and they need to know what, what they’re up against. And then the second time he brought me to the side was when we were walking through to get like, sort of like a general, you know, chance to walk around a little bit, even though we’d already been but a little walk around.

And he, and he talks to me and he says, you know, we have a lot of pressure here from um, different, you know, ethnic groups, right? We have pressure, I have, I have a lot of pressure from the Germans, the Italians, the Polish, the Irish, Jewish, and on and off. And it was all white groups. So it, he named six about, and it was all white ethnic groups that he just literally named to me.

He did not say one group of color and, and not one community of color in the entire, in, in the entire city. So that was mind blowing. Um, and I shared those comments. So essentially he was like, we want to leave out the students. And just to let you know, there’s a lot of pressure here to keep it like that, you know, and, and to focus on those groups .And, and I’m pretty accountable to that. That was his message.

So once the students understood that they, you know, they understood it was gonna be a fight, and that got them, I think even more, you know, inspired, right? I think it’s like, oppression breeds resistance. And it’s true, the students were revved up by that and so they, that inspired them to better navigate, you know, the next steps.

GONZALES: They have determined from the moment of the visit to the History Museum that their voices are going to be heard.  They are very brave in standing up in this room full of adults and I mean that metaphorically and you know literally they’re standing up on social media they’re standing up at the news media they’re standing up in these meetings, and they’re speaking out they’re saying you know what “We’re not gonna be silenced we’re not gonna be sidelined this is our project, no you can’t resolve this in the quiet with the adults and just paper this over”, and so yeah. I’m very proud of them and I think the reason I keep wanting to tell their story and keeping their story so central project is not only because it’s theirs and because they earned it but also because I know that their story can inspire so many more young people like them and I’m hoping that many young people who visit the history museum or encounter this project in various ways are inspired to make change in their communities as well

BETEND: This is the part of the story where Elena starts to take center stage. In addition to her position as curator of community engagement and social justice, Elena is also the lead curator on Aquí en Chicago. She was hired specifically for the role, representing just one of the students’ victories.

But she’s also stepping into the project a couple years in, with pressure to make up for lost time.

GONZALES: The History Museum was starting out in a deficit position. We did not have the relationships. We did not have the collections that would make this project possible

BETEND: And she was stepping into a role that came with heavy expectations.

GONZALES:  One of the challenging things when I stepped into this role is that the expectation was to represent all of Latine Chicago, which is not one community, it’s a third of the city. It’s many communities that are connected in important ways.

BETEND: Coming up, how do you appropriately represent a diverse group of people from more than 20 countries of heritage, sometimes with vastly different backgrounds and cultures?

…People connected, at times, by little more than others prejudice, or the means by which they came to America? Maybe just the color of their skin.

Other times, bound together by a common struggle for recognition, or fight for liberty–

–And do it all in 4,000 sq ft.?

(Music)

BETEND: You’ve probably noticed my or Elena’s use of the phrase Latine, a few times during this podcast. It’s a gender-neutral alternative to Latino/Latina, and while it’s increasing in popularity, especially among younger spanish speakers, it’s true that lots of people prefer other terms

GONZALES: The history museum as a whole has chosen to use o/a/e. That’s not very practical for us to say. My goal is just to be inclusive

BETEND: In the interest of inclusivity, we’ve decided to use the term people prefer. So at times we may switch between Latine or Latino, but the truth is most people don’t actually prefer either of those terms, anyway.

GONZALES: When it comes to this set of communities, often you won’t even hear people say Latino, Latina, Latine or anything like that. You’ll hear them say Mexican or Puerto Rican or Cuban or what have you.

BETEND: Typically people identify with their heritage. Where more general terms like Latine can be helpful in the context of American history, is when we’re trying not to be too specific:

Both “Latine” and “Latino”, or “Latina” try to recognize a wide group of people who often share common experiences — like migration or colonization — but come from very different countries and cultures. Sometimes these groups have been bundled together by outsiders, other times, grouped together by choice. In terms of describing any individual person’s characteristics and experiences, Latine is about as descriptive as saying ‘brown,’ or ‘person of color.’
Interestingly, the term Latino itself was born right here in Chicago in the early 1970s —

GONZALES: “Chicago is the first place that Latino was actually used as an umbrella term to band people together politically

BETEND: The story goes that during the Civil Rights Movement, Mexican and Puerto Rican workers were demanding fair hiring practice from Illinois Bell, the telephone company. Instead of approaching the company separately, the workers united under the one identity of Latino.
Respectfully representing any one culture is already challenging, but the concept of Aquí went well beyond that.

We’re also talking about history that might not have been well preserved.

Plus, museums typically display…things. While they do use plaques or signs, the main way museums communicate is with objects.

GONZALES: When we have a gap in the historical record where we don’t have the correct materials because those materials have been lost a time… one thing that I think is really helpful is to bring in artist artwork to fill those gaps.

BETEND: One of the objects you’ll find if you visit Aquí in person, is an acoustic guitar. It’s accompanied by an old case, road-worn with stickers.

GONZALES: The other thing is, who is doing the work when institutions are falling short? And the answer is community-based historians, and that can look a lot of different ways.

BETEND: Both the guitar and case belonged to a man whose life was dedicated to preserving the history Elena was looking for: legendary Mexican American folk singer and scholar, Dr. Jesús “Chuy” Negrete.

(Music)

BETEND: Chuy was a master of the Corrido, a form of Mexican ballad, whose lyrics often tell stories ripped directly from history.

GONZALES: Chuy Negrete was precisely one of these community-based historians who was in the business of preserving his community’s history.

BETEND: Chuy’s authentic style was his signature: salt-and-pepper goatee, almost always wearing a cowboy hat, and very likely a wide grin.

(Music)

GONZALES: He was an ethnomusicologist and a musician and he did this work in a very specific way which is through the art form of the corrido.

BETEND: He sang about the lives of those around him: the plight of farm workers and immigrants, as well as tales of migration and revolution. Of surviving struggle and outwitting adversity.

Here’s a piece of a story written by broadcaster Linda Lutton, for Chicago’s public radio station, WBEZ, celebrating Chuy’s life and music.

LINDA LUTTON, WBEZ: Imagine having a song writer who followed you through life, from one country to the next, and sang of your trials and victories, your history. That’s what Chuy Negrete did for Mexican immigrants and their children.

Here he’s singing about all the jobs Mexican immigrants come North for, “I picked cherries in Minnesota, took care of dogs in North Dakota, I worked the mines of Arizona…”

BETEND: In just a few words Lutton is able to capture why Chuy remains such a beloved figure with so many in the city, and beyond.

According to Chuy’s widow, Rita Rousseau, the topics he sang about were often close to his heart.

RITA ROUSSEAU: They had been farm workers in Texas when he was, when he was little. So he had, um, a specific affinity with, um, the farm worker

BETEND: Chuy’s family came to Texas through America’s Bracero guest worker program, which offered immigrants hard agricultural jobs for a chance at receiving citizenship.

When he was 7, Chuy’s family moved to South Chicago for work in the steel mills. It was there, in the newly forming Mexican community, Chuy was first introduced to the guitar.

ROUSSEAU:  He learned how to play guitar from his neighbor and at church.

FRANK CORONA:  His father was a steel worker.…I lived on 87th. He lived on 91st and Houston.

BETEND: Frank Corona remembers growing up in the same neighborhood as Chuy.

CORONA: And, uh, I played the guitar. He played the guitar

BETEND: They became good friends. Later, Frank would tag along when Chuy’s music pulled him onto the road.

CORONA:  But Chuy was amazing. Dr. Negrete was amazing. We traveled the Southwest in the, the circuit for the Chicano movement

BETEND: Chuy’s interest in Mexican history and music brought him into the budding Chicano movement where he eventually met labor organizer Cesar Chavez and participated in protests for the United Farm Workers Union

ROUSSEAU: Cesar Chavez was in South Chicago and he was just, you know, fascinated by him and just truly inspired.

BETEND: His music became a regular part of Chavez’s United Farm Workers rallies and a fixture at protests around the city. Chuy was as comfortable performing at Universities and museums, as he was from the back of a flat bed truck. Invited or not.

Performing uninvited is actually how Rita and Chuy first met.

ROUSSEAU: Okay. I love that story.

Um, it was the opening of the Dia de los Muertos exhibit at the Mexican Museum, which is now called the National Museum of Mexican Art in 1988. And, um, I had come just ’cause I had the, the use of somebody’s car

BETEND: Rita was in the neighborhood and figured she’d just stop by and check it out.

ROUSSEAU:  And he had come with his guitar and was going around and singing and playing appropriate songs. And I thought that was just wonderful. I just, but it turns out that he had, that he had just done that on his own, you know, the next time he went, they said he had to confiscate the guitar, but…

GONZALES: So it wasn’t part of the program?

ROUSSEAU: Not, not officially, but could have fooled me, you know, and I was like, I was like following him around because I thought, this guy’s really good.

BETEND: Afterwards the two sat in his car and talked. He was thrilled to discover she spoke Spanish.

ROUSSEAU:  And he said, “Oh, you’ll have such pretty babies.” You know that was that. So that’s really sweet. It happened really quickly.

GONZALES:  He was the voice of the Chicano movement and he was the voice of the labor movement

BETEND: Negrete was regularly referred to as “The Chicano Woodie Guthrie.” It’s a comparison he seems to have approved of based on one of the many stickers slapped on his guitar case over the years seems to be a winking reference

ROUSSEAU: The case was kind of interesting because, you know, he kind of just slapped every poster on it, and at one point, I think he had one that said, “This machine kills fascists” you know, which is the, um, Woody Guthrie quote.

BETEND: Guthrie famously used to scrawl those words on his own guitar in thick black chicken-scratch.

CORONA:  He was always into education. He was a speaker, a singer, and uh, he traveled a lot to Southwest.

I used to say, Chuy, take me with you. You know, I’ll give you a second guitar, second voice.

BETEND: Radio legend Studs Terkel interviewed Chuy Negrete for his radio show in 1997.

STUDS TERKEL: Jesús Negrete, known as Chuy, he’s a folklorist, folk singer, musicologist and professor of Latino studies, and he’s known as the ‘Chicano Woody Guthrie,’ and he sing songs, corridos, which are story songs,

…he is a historian who sings the stories of his people

BETEND: Chuy described the importance of the corrido as a sort of newspaper set to music.

CHUY GARCIA: The corrido was utilized to preserve their history because in 1910 the Mexican population was basically 80% illiterate so they used this oral tradition to keep alive their history and to make political commentary. It was their stories, it was their history books. The corrido then is to the Chicano, the Mexican-American, what the Blues is to the Black man.

BETEND: Chuy was also funny; remarkably quick witted and spontaneous.

Here he is singing to a group of college students at University of Iowa about the experience of coming to an American classroom and suddenly getting a new name..

(LANCC performance)
If you were called Alberto, they called you Bert. Lorenzo, la-la-la-la-larry, Domingo, sunday. I knew a guy his name was Domingo Nieve, they called him Ice Cream Sunday. [laughs]

BETEND: But he was deeply serious about the importance of the corrido as a cultural tool. He told that same audience about the experience of performing for incarcerated men who are often surprised to find themselves crying.

GARCIA: When I play for incarcerated men, when I play a song, they cry. “I tell them brothers that’s what you’re supposed to do.”

The corrido also redistributes grief. It redistributes the grief so it can be born again. So the corrido has helped our people, psychologically, like mental health.

BETEND: In the song he tells the story of the Mexican general Pancho Villa’s dying words to his grief-stricken men.

(Music)

BETEND: In response to their anguished question of what to do once he was gone, Villa’s advice, carried on his final breath, “write a corrido”

(LANCC performance)
And that’s the culture war. I’m saying that these ideas are old ideas.

ROUSSEAU:  He had this chant about, um, Gigi Mecca or you know, Azteca da da, you know, Chicano. Um, in the, talking about the creation of the race.

(Song shouts “Mestizo”)

ROUSSEAU But they were like punctuation points of his show at the beginning and the end that were just very emotional. Um, so, and he had a thing at the end of that, uh, you know, you must know your history so you can not repeat your history so you can go out and make history. And you know, I don’t think that was an original quote, he got that from someone else.

BETEND: I would argue, the most meaningful songs that Chuy composed actually weren’t meant to be performed on stage.

ROUSSEAU: He had a project where he would write Memorial Coditos for funerals for like, you know, anybody.

(Music)

ROUSSEAU: Somebody would say, you know, my mom died and, and he would go talk to them about, things that happened in her life and where she was born and what she did and who her kids were and so forth, and write a corrido and then he would come and perform it and they’d have it all typed out and it would be something that’s really, really meaningful to these people.

You know, they weren’t like famous people. They were just working class people and to have their Grandma or dad or, you know, whoever’s cousin memorialized in that way was, you know, it was, it was a big contribution.

GONZALES: I didn’t realize that he did that for other people

ROUSSEAU: No it was just kind of a mission that he had

GONZALES: That’s really beautiful

BETEND: Corridos historically can be both comedy or tragedy and political commentary is baked into the tradition. One popular sub-genre are corridos about immigration with plucky migrants and immigration officials, or Migra, playing central characters in a cat-and-mouse game that would become increasingly deadly in recent years.

These tensions are well documented in the early history of the corrido. From humorous references to Immigration officials who crack down most of the year only to look the other way during harvest season, to cautionary tales about the promises of America itself.

In a popular song titled, El Lavaplatos, or the Dishwasher, written in 1930, its composer Jesús Osorio tells a tale of an immigrant newly landed in California, gleeful about having made it across the border without having to pay the fee. His head swimming with dreams of Hollywood, he goes on to work a series of menial jobs before finally returning to Mexico “poorer than when I left there.”

The song became a hit, so much so that three different versions of the song were recorded by different groups on the exact same day, July 1st, 1930, according to copyright.

Another hint of the cultural significance of the corrido is the fact that the US Government has used it for propaganda.

In 2014, the Border Patrol commissioned a series of so-called Migra corridos as part of a campaign to dissuade illegal immigration. This story comes to us from a fascinating blog post Chicago History Museum curatorial fellow, Algae Guzmán. The songs were composed by an American ad agency and distributed to radio stations across South and Central America.

Now, here’s the odd part. One song in particular might have inadvertently become a hit. In 2019, multiple news outlets reported that radio stations were getting calls requesting the song and asking about the artists, completely unaware it was an official production of US border patrol. “La Bestia” or “The Beast” is the nickname for a network of freight trains used by many migrants in their journey North. In reality, riding “The Beast” is extremely dangerous, exposing travelers to numerous perils both from the train itself but also gangs that patrol along the route. The song’s chorus describes the train as an almost-mythical creature

They call her The Beast from the South
This wretched train of death,
With the devil in the boiler
Whistles, roars, twists and turns.

(Music grows)

While it’s unclear how popular the song ever became, but it certainly seems possible that without a blaring “produced by the US Government” sticker on the front, people genuinely took the song to be a celebration of surviving a harrowing journey.

GONZALES:  When a powerful entity like the United states government tries to usurp a cultural form that’s an acknowledgement of its power … so I think there’s two ways to see it

GARCIA: When life is harshest for Mexicans and the border, and in Mexico, their folkloric production is at its highest.

BETEND: In his interview with Studs Terkel, Chuy spoke about the relationship between his music and politics.

GARCIA: They say the folk song is not the political struggle, but you can’t have the political struggle without the folk song. They go hand in hand. And it doesn’t take the place of the political action, but you can hardly have the political action without the music.

BETEND: Music was the way in.

And if Chuy was the music, the politician was his friend Rudy.

(Rudy’s May Day Speech, 1979)

BETEND: May Day, 1979, a man in a heavy jacket stands on a stage in front of a crowd in downtown Chicago, his thick black hair is buffeted by the Spring breeze. At the height of his swift political rise, Rudy Lozano was arguably the most important Latino political figure in the city.

LOZANO: I would like to begin by saluting this effort in the face of one of the most hardest times confronting the working class in this country,

BETEND: The Chicago Reader described his posthumous influence over politics in his community as near-biblical, a timeline splitting event. There was “before Rudy,” and then there was “after Rudy.”

GARY RIVLIN: That’s the significance to me of Rudy Lozano, that this is before and after period where you know, it was a lot of apathy. Uh, there was a lot of fear. Mm-hmm.

BETEND: In an article published two years after Lozano’s death, reporter Gary Rivlin grapples in poignant and often exhaustive detail with the life, death, and legacy of Rudy Lozano. He writes: “When he ran for office in 1983 he awakened his neighborhood’s 100,000 plus Latinos who previously mostly didn’t vote, propelling him to within a whisker of being elected Alderman… He wasn’t just the first Latino to challenge the white machine that ruled his ward, 75 percent latino and 16 percent white, he was more. He awakened people.”

RIVLIN: Uh, there was very low voter registration. It was almost like politics was something over there with the white folks. It was the Chicago machine. Very powerful. Uh, then, and you know, you got something for your vote. Like, if you vote for us, we’ll give you better services. We’ll help you out. If you wanna get rid of a refrigerator, your kid gets in a little bit of trouble. You know, that kind of, that kind of thing. Lozano took that on. He was organizing against some pretty powerful forces, outside forces, uh, in the, in the community.

BETEND: Just like Chuy, Rudy’s family landed in Texas before relocating to South Chicago. Around the same time Chuy was learning his first guitar chords, Rudy was organizing his first protest.

RIVLIN: But then he got into union organizing. There were these, uh, tortilla factories and they hired a lot of people. And the more Lozano looked in, and this is based on my reporting, this is alleged. Um, but I heard it from several people. So I came to believe it was true that, um, the Mexican mafia, whatever you wanna call it, organized crime, was really strong there.

BETEND: In 1979 he joined the International Ladies Garment Workers Union.

He climbed quickly up the ranks. According to Rivlin, the Union’s vice president described Rudy as having a “mind like a computer.”

Within two years he’d become the union’s Midwest Regional Organizing Director — that let him call the shots – And the first targets Rudy set his sights on were the tortilla factories.

He started with Del Rey, the biggest of the two factories in Chicago. To others around Rudy, it seemed like a strange choice: Del Rey only employed around 110 workers, many of them undocumented, making it less likely they’d want to put their employment, or ability to stay in the country, at risk by organizing.

RIVLIN: They had a pay to come, and the deal was they’d work 60 hours and get paid for 40, and it turned out to be more like indentured servitude. They could never pay it back. And so they’re living in lousy conditions, they’re working 60 hours a week and they really can’t get out of it. And so Lozano was taking on powerful forces.

BETEND: Though skeptical, The Union’s vice president, Lou Montenegro, was unable to talk his new director out of the idea, he told Rivlin, “Rudy’s only concern was with the people.”

When I think about union organizing, uh, just from my own experiences I think of like maybe a person with a clipboard, like making sure everyone has water or something like that. But this was very different, right? I mean, uh, what was union organizing looking like at this point in time?

RIVLIN: So a lot of scared people. What Rudy Lozano had to do is go into people’s kitchens, go into the living rooms, meet with them, talk to them, explain to them that, you know, standing up is important and will help yourself, your people, maybe your kids. And you know, it’s, it’s drifting back to the bosses that you know, this guy, this young guy is trying to upset what they have.

BETEND: Lou made Rudy convince the rest of the board on his own because he was too embarrassed to suggest the idea himself.

RIVLIN: And so this was a very exciting time, but also a very scary time ’cause there were threats. You know, there were threats against Lozano with a gun, uh, as a union organizer. There were threats, uh, in Pilsen against those taking on the forces there. I mean, I felt it a little bit too, you know, I did an interview. I’m, you know, there at midnight and, you know, just, just, you’re looking over your shoulder when you hear these kinds of, these kinds of, uh, stories that you know, these are people that don’t want stories, uh, to get out. Rudy Lozano was threatening to expose it through his work.

BETEND: The truth is that Lou was right about the challenge ahead of them; the effort would be long and drawn out, intense and hostile. In fact, it wouldn’t be completed until after Rudy Lozano’s death.

(Music)

BETEND: One of the memorial corridos written by Chuy Negrete was composed for the funeral of his dear friend, Rudy Lozano.

(Music)

BETEND: On the morning of June 9th, 1983, Rudy Lozano was shot and killed in the kitchen of his home. He was 31. His wife, Lupe Lozano, and youngest son, David, were in the house at the time.

Lupe’s father, who lived a few doors away, provided police with one of the few clues: a fleeting glimpse of someone who looked to be in their 20s, wearing a backwards baseball cap, who peddled past on a blue bicycle down the alley away from the Lozano house.

Rivlin writes, “Within hours, hundreds of mourners had flocked to the Lozano home. His body still lay inside. Within days his face was peering out from the plate glass windows of most stores around the barrio, on a poster bordered in black.”

Written across were the words “Un hijo del pueblo,” ‘a son of the people.’

There was considerable pressure on police to find the person responsible.

RIVLIN: I remember counting, there were 15 detectives. It’s what the police called the heater case, that there’s a lot of press attention.

BETEND: For the next few weeks they would follow a winding series of leads and tips that brought them to the backrooms of multiple tortilla factories and the backalleys of City Hall.

Rivlin writes, “After three weeks detectives learned the whereabouts of the murder weapon. The tip came through an anonymous call to Channel 7.”

A few days later an 18 year old, Gregory Escobar, would be charged with the murder.

(Music)

BETEND: At Rudy Lozano’s funeral, thousands marched in a procession for 3 hours. The mayor Harold Washington made a speech. Rudy had been his “liaison to the Latino community” and his efforts had played a crucial role in Washington’s successful bid.

Chuy performed the corrido he’d written in Rudy’s honor.

(Music)

BETEND: Escobar would eventually be convicted. But it would take multiple trials. The jury in his first trial was conflicted about the state’s lack of evidence and unconvinced by the DA’s argument. He was convicted a month later by a 2nd jury after 6 hours of deliberation.

For many of Lozano’s friends and family, convicting Escobar was only the beginning. To them it wasn’t a question of if Rudy’s politics were involved, but which of his many activities had led to his death.

In front of the crowd gathered for the memorial, Chuy and his guitar gave voice to what so many were thinking:

(Corrido)
That’s why they say it was Escobar. That’s why they say that it was Escobar.
Pero la gente no confía en las historias de policía,
(fades under)

BETEND: ‘…But people don’t believe the stories of the police.’

(Corrido)
Pero la gente no confía en las historias de policía, (fades under)

RIVLIN:  There were informants that came forward and like, you know. Yeah, maybe they were lying.

Maybe it was a made up story, but like one of them the police didn’t even talk to, um, instead they had their preferred performance, who was kind of the middleman for the gun, for Greg Escobar, the shooter. And you know, they kind of bought his story and I’m thinking like, okay, well maybe he’s telling the truth, but he certainly is a tainted source.

And I’m really interested in what these other informants, uh, are, are saying, you know. I sat down with one of them, and you know, they say they overheard a conversation at one of the tortilla factories, um, about, that he thought was about killing Rudy Lozano. And you’re like, okay, well the guy was murdered.

Uh, why don’t we really kinda shake that tree? Why don’t we really pursue that aggressively?

BETEND: In the days after the funeral, a commission was formed to seek justice for Lozano. It was made up of friends, family, fellow activists and even a few local politicians. They wanted Rudy’s death investigated as a political assassination and they wanted to know who put Escobar up to it. Their fear was that arresting Escobar would give the police a reason to give up on investigating any further. In many ways, their fears were justified.

RIVLIN: Within a few weeks they figure out the one who pulled the trigger.

Um, and that’s where it stopped. The case literally closed a few weeks later. And I, you know, I think to myself like.

Wait, if this was. An Irish politician who came within 17 votes of the runoff in an automatic race if it was Polish. I mean, even in Black and White Chicago, it was a Black, um, politician who was gunned down like that, but it just seemed in Chicago then that. Latinos didn’t count.

You know what I mean? Like everyone’s Black and White and you know, Latino was just this other thing that didn’t fit into their, into their equation. I really feel like that had a big impact on everything here. The coverage or lack of coverage of Lozano, but more the point, the investigation afterwards into who killed him.

(Music)

BETEND: Here’s the short version of what happens next: In the reckless pursuit of an easier conviction, the state enshrines its version of the story in testimony and court documents. A story that the Lozano family found as offensive as it was ridiculous; That Rudy Lozano was murdered over a drug debt.

That’s the version of the story I encountered first, repeated in articles, then in the verdict convicting Escobar.

And it’s a story that not even the police believed.

The reality is that there is a chasm sized divergence between many of the communities lived experience and the official narrative

RIVLIN: Here’s the problem.

That’s the story from the guy who’s confessed. But the police did investigate that and just found out he was a really straight-laced fellow. He had nothing to do with drugs. He complained about rock and roll music ’cause it was too drug oriented. He was not into drugs.

BETEND: So how was it possible that the DA was able to convince the jury of a narrative that not even the cases detectives believed. In order to explain, it’s best to start with what everyone believes took place.

In her kitchen, two years later, Lupe Lozano sat with Chicago Reader reporter Gary Rivlin to recount the events of that morning.

RIVLIN:  It’s nine in the morning.

He’s still in his t-shirt and doesn’t even have his shirt on. Um, there’s a knock at the back door and someone’s making a case that they need to make a phone call. And Rudy Lozano, generous, Rudy Lozano. Some of his, you know, friends, cohorts called him naive sometimes, you know, let’s the guy in, um, to make his phone call.

BETEND: Lupe was in bed in the next room when she heard the knock on the back door. The conversation struck her as odd. “The voice asked ‘Where’s your wife?’” Lupe later told the jury that found Escobar guilty. “That’s when I lifted my head to listen closely.”

“She said the visitor spoke with her husband in a ‘familiar, relaxed way, like they knew each other.’ Ever since she has racked her brains trying to place a voice that still eludes her.

Lupe thought at first the gunshots were firecrackers popping, only when her mind registered her son David crying did she realize what had happened.”

In their interview Lupe, described the impact on their three sons, “their eldest, Rudy Jr., 9, who was nine at the time planned on one day occupying the Mayor’s office, “They all want to be candidates.” Lupe told Rivlin, “Sometimes they draw political posters, put on their suits and walk around the house campaigning. When they’re mad at each other they withdraw endorsements.”

(Music)

BETEND: “Escobar was hauled in the afternoon of July 3rd, and early on Independence day confessed to the murder. Rivlin writes, “The police closed the case four weeks after it opened, and proudly awaited the applause they would never hear.”

RIVLIN: The police dropped it,  the state’s attorney. That was the big hope for the Lozano family, that this would go to the state’s attorney and Richard M Daley was the state’s attorney at the time. He would understand it. He had the clout, he had the juice to like really push.

But, you know, he’s a prosecutor with a record to defend and all they really cared about it seemed to me was closing the case, notching the win. Okay. We solved this case and that was that.

BETEND: I believe the result of that first trial is it ends up in a mistrial, right? The jury is just hopefully deadlocked-

RIVLIN: -the jury was hopelessly confused. (Laughter) Well, why did this guy do it? And there’s conflicting stories and so, you know, I mean, that’s the problem. And not fully, fully investigating, uh, a case. There are holes, and I think the jury saw the holes.

I really think you can’t understand the Lozano case without understanding there was an undercurrent of race and, you know, some of it was racism, but there was this weird, or arguably more insidious form that they didn’t count. You know, the racism from the white community was directed in another, you know, community then.

RIVLIN: And so, the prosecutors’ working theory was that naive Rudy Lozano got in the way of this gang rivalry, gang warfare, and he was a casualty.

Is it possible? Yes. Is it possible that Rudy Lozano somehow got in the way of a gang thing he didn’t understand? But there are also informants who were pointing at the tortilla factories. In fact, I got a call, I got two calls. Uh, the story appears on a Thursday and at two in the morning I’m up with the music on and I get a threatening call, like, you know, “continue writing on the tortilla factories and you’re dead”, kind of thing. I mean, I can’t remember exactly 40 plus years later. And you know, in my head, like I was scared but like, haha you didn’t wake me up. Um, and then at 6:00 AM I was asleep. And they called again. And, you know, whatever threat they gave was just a different version of the same threat.

BETEND: Wow.

RIVLIN: I remember ever, ever since that pair of phone calls, I was pretty convinced it was the tortilla factories.

I’m pretty shocked that the story wasn’t advanced, that in whatever, 30 plus years, that nothing’s come out. I mean, that’s a shame, I- we have our theories. Everyone can believe what they want to believe. It would be nice if someone in power cared. My beef is with the police of the time. My beef is with the state’s attorney at the time. And so to me I think the crime so to speak was committed in 1983, 1984, 1985, both the police and the state’s attorney said “Okay, we know what we need to know. We got our conviction.” Honestly, it just broke my heart that there wasn’t more attention. It was eye opening, and you know,

I guess if we’re looking for any silver linings and a tragedy, it really opened my eyes. I mean, it became very important for me after that, uh, to continue reporting, uh, about, um, Latino empowerment, I remember interviewing this cab driver, um, Luis Gutiérrez. And of course he went on to be, you know, US Congressman, Luis Gutiérrez. You know, Juan Solis, you know, he went on to become a state representative. I talked to him and, you know, one of those Mexican restaurants in Pilsen when he was working a less glamorous job than that. So, you know, I really kind of made it my business, after that, I mean, I guess that’s the way you could say Rudy Lozano continued to inspire after he was killed.

Harold Washington really cared about the Latino community in large part, I believe because Rudy Lozado, he made that connection. They made that connection over shared politics. They made a human connection. They’re both kind of, you know, warm, gregarious people trying to represent their community, and I think there was a real connection there. And Harold Washington to his credits, to me, he really helped empower Latinos. And I think a large part of that was the human connection he made with a fellow politician.

I really think he helped light a light, a fire, a spark. And again, within a few years of his murder, assassination, there were, I think, four Latinos elected to the Chicago City Council by the end of the decade. There were Latinos in the State House. Uh, and, you know, and I really think you can draw that to Lozano. I mean, there are others. It wasn’t just Rudy Lozano. Sure. Uh, but he was a, he, he was a critical figure, a pivotal figure to my mind in, uh, Latino politics in Chicago, kind of an activist turn, union organizer turned politician and gunned down at 31 before he could fully see his life.

(Music)

BETEND: The incredible achievements of Rudy Lozano’s life were carried on by his family, in particular his sister, Emma Lozano. Later by his sons David, Pepe, and Rudy Jr. On July 18th, 2023, Rudy Lozano Jr. was appointed to the Board of Education by Mayor Brandon Johnson.

Rudy’s legacy has been admirably carried on by the students of IJLA.

(Music)

BETEND: Dr. Chuy Negrete’s guitar and harmonicas, as well as a full version of his corrido written for Rudy Lozano will be on display when Aquí en Chicago opens its doors on October 25th.

(Music)

BETEND: One final thought for this episode. Throughout the production process we struggled with how to acknowledge the present political moment we’re preparing to open this exhibition in.

–And then the present came up and smacked us in the face.

GONZALES: [quietly] The news has been changing by the day, and you’ll leave work-

BETEND: A few months ago, I joined our regular production meeting and Elena, who is usually super calm, seemed incredibly stressed.

GONZALES:  Ah, I am very pleased to say that we are still planning to open Aquí on time-

April 2nd, we received termination notices for the grants from the National Endowment for the Humanities, stating that our grants no longer effectuated the agency’s needs and priorities. Particularly, that the NEH is repurposing its funding allocations in a new direction in furtherance of the President’s agenda. And our immediate grant termination was necessary to safeguard the interests of the federal government, including its fiscal priorities.

BETEND: The Chicago History Museum received letters informing Elena and her team that all four federal grants that were funding the creation of Aquí en Chicago had been cancelled.

GONZALES: It actually says, “The termination of your grant represents an urgent priority for the administration.”

BETEND: Wow.

GONZALES: So that’s a real slap in the face. We are at a place where we are so far along, it would be in some ways institutionally, a much heavier lift not to do it.

BETEND:  This seems kind of like a strange question but do you think of the work that you’re doing as transgressive?

GONZALES: [laughs] I certainly didn’t…I think of the work that I’m doing as strongly morally and ethically guided…  so, i don’t view that as being transgressive but i think in the current context it absolutely is.

BETEND: Next time, on Building Aqui.

Building Aqui is co-created by Elena Gonzales and Jesse Betend. The show is written and hosted by Jesse Betend, with additional editing by Elena Gonzales, Chila Soloman, and Sydney Polosquez.

The show is produced by Jesse Betend, and Rob Lafrenz. These are just some of the stories contained in the Aquí en Chicago exhibit. We hope that you will join us in person to explore gorgeous, sparkling quinceanera gowns, architectural artifacts and indigenous art. Next episode we will explore how Rudy Lozano’s efforts to elect Harold Washington led to an executive order which became the foundation of Chicago’s sanctuary city policies.

How Chicago came to have some of the strongest protections for undocumented people in the country, and how it’s painted a target on the city’s back. A thank you to Tama McDonald, without whom this project would not exist. This podcast also wouldn’t be possible without the hard work of everyone behind the Aquí en Chicago exhibit, including Elena’s supporting curatorial colleagues Jojo Galvan Mora, digital humanities fellow, and Rebekah Coffman, curator of religion and community history. As well as 43 advisors, 26 story tellers, 29 interns, and 10 volunteers.

Special thanks to Rita Rosou, for permission to use music from the late, great Chicano Woody Guthry himself, Chuy Negrete. It’s no corrido, but I hope this episode brought warm memories to the many people who loved him. Thanks also to Gary Rivlin, whose article I found incredibly inspiring and was itself very nearly lost to time. I was able to find it because he happened to have a scanned PDF copy of the actual Chicago Reader posted to his website. I haven’t come across anything that explores the story in anywhere near as much depth, and I highly suggest giving it a read. You will find a link to it, as well as a blog post about the history of the Corrido in the show notes for this episode. I am Jesse Betend, thank you for listening.

(Corrido plays)

Episode 2: Sound & Faith

For more than forty years, Chicago has called itself a Sanctuary City—but what does that promise really mean?

Through the stories of Adriana Portillo-Bartow, a Guatemalan mother fleeing military terror in the 1980s; and Elvira Arellano, whose stand inside a Humboldt Park church after 9/11 reignited a national movement, CHM curator Rebekah Coffman reflects on three distinct waves of the city’s historic promise.

CHM_Aqui_PodcastGraphic_Episode2_1400x1400_5

Episode 2: Sound & Faith Transcript

(Music)

JESSE BETEND: A bus pulls to a dusty stop in the border city of Tapachula, Mexico.

The people waiting at the stop begin filing in. Among the people filing on are a family, a woman, a man and two small girls.

The woman’s name is Adriana Portillo-Bartow, but for the next few years she would be leaving that name behind.

The bus was headed to the capitol, Mexico City. Away from her home of Guatemala. Away from the people who called her by that old name.

Adriana, her husband and their two daughters fled Guatemala with barely more than the clothes they were wearing and a wad of cash. The money had been hand delivered by a representative of the Mexican Government,  and it had come with a warning:

ADRIANA PORTILLO-BARTOW: They said, “We can get her out; she needs to get out immediately.”

BETEND: She would enter America crawling on her stomach. Her two daughters, 4 and 7, beside her in the Arizona dirt. They would make it, thanks to a small group of Americans - Two  Pastors and a Nun, dedicated to helping refugees fleeing the violence of the US-backed Guatemalan and Salvadoran Governments. Even though it meant breaking the law.

From Rivet and the Chicago History Museum, this is Building Aquí

Before the family could even begin the journey to America, they would first have to make the solo trip to meet their sanctuary guides in Mexico City.

Getting visas to enter Mexico had been simple enough. Now they settled back into their seats as the bus creaked into motion down a road pock-marked by immigration checkpoints.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: There were, like,  probably five or six migra [immigration agents], booths, or stops.

BETEND: Not knowing what to expect when they arrived at the first checkpoint, Adrianna and her husband divided the money that they had between them. Just in case.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: So at the first stop, they pulled us out. They separated the children, separated the women, and they separated the men.

BETEND: The immigration agents begin checking the men’s identification. Meanwhile one-by-one the women were waved into a small booth.

PORTILLO-BARTOW:  Only the women…So when it was my turn, you know, I went

BETEND: Inside was another agent, sitting behind a wooden desk. The boss-migra starts asking her questions.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: I told him, we are tourists. We are going to Mexico City.

And he said, ‘Well, don't you know that for you to be a tourist, you gotta have a certain amount of money?’

And I said, ‘I have it, I have it. But I only have half, and my husband has half.’

And so he said, ‘Let me see the money.’

And I said, ‘No, I have the money. You have to believe me. Why am I gonna show you the money?’

He said, ‘Let me see the money.’

And I said, ‘No.’

So he got a gun out and put it on the table.

And said, ‘Let me see the money.’

BETEND: Adriana hands him the money and he quickly counts the cash. When he’s done he looks up at her.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: “You don't have the money that you are required. You only have half. You only have half of what you say you have here.”

And I said, “no, I counted my money like two hours ago and I know how much I had.” He said, “No, you don't have that. Mm-hmm. Here, here is your money.”

BETEND: The agent hands Adrianna half of the money she’d given him. He places the other half in the drawer of the desk in front of him.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: “You can leave.”

BETEND: She does.

(Music)

BETEND: As they approached the next checkpoint, Adriana and her husband again split the money they had left.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: The same story. Mm-hmm. The same story. They stole half of the money.

And then with a gun and the legs like this on the table and then, ‘Leave. You can go now. Leave, leave. Before I change my mind.’

And we got to Mexico City, didn't have money, just a few pesos for some tacos, you know, nothing, no money for hotel, nothing.

And at the terminal in Mexico City where the bus arrived. You know, they say that the Mexican migra is very well trained. They know when people are not Mexican. Mm-hmm. I don't know why. Maybe the attitude, the fear, I don't know. Mm-hmm. The thing is that we were just there, you know? And thinking you know what to do. You know, we're trying to figure out where the bus mm-hmm.

The next bus, you know, uh, we need to take, you know, then a migra guy comes and looks at me and says, you come here, come follow me.

BETEND: The agent takes her into a small office in the bus terminal and once again begins the shakedown routine she’s expecting.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Puts the gun there and say, “What are you doing here?”

“We are tourists,” The same story, you know?

“Do you have the money that you're required to have here?”

“No, I don't. Because all your compinches- I said all your, you know, your mafia stole everything. Mm-hmm. Throughout the way. They stole all the money that we had. Mm-hmm. So I don't have any money. You can search me. I don't have any money, and if you don't let me go right now, I'm going to go to the police and I'm going to denounce you.”

I was shaking. I was shaking. But I told the man that I will denounce you that you and all your compinches stole our money. Mm-hmm. That's the way you treat the tourists that come to your country. I will go to the media too, and he just looked at me. Mm.

“You know what, I'm gonna give you five minutes for you to disappear. Mm-hmm. And in five minutes, I see you again. You will know who I am.”

And I said, okay, thank you. And I got up and my husband was outside, you know. Let's run, let's run, let's go, let's go, let's go. And we ran. Mm-hmm. Ran and ran and ran. We ended up, Mexico is this giant, huge city that we didn't know, you know, but we got lost among, you know, the thousands of people that were on the streets.

(“Whispers” song w/ humming and organ transitions into church bell field recording to bring us back to street level)

BETEND: I'm Jesse Betend and this is Building Aquí, a podcast exploring the stories contained in The Chicago History Museum's new exhibition, Aquí En Chicago.

On this episode, we’re exploring the history of how Chicago came to be a sanctuary city.

The origins of the sanctuary movement in the 1980s as civil disobedience, where religious leaders and average Americans risked the threat of arrest and worse to provide safety to refugees fleeing violence.

How it painted a target on a city that's being tested like never before.

DONALD TR*MP: Well, we’re going in. We’re going in, I didn’t say when. We’re going in.

(Sounds of protest)

BETEND: When they finally stopped running, Adrianna found a phone and contact the people waiting to meet them in Mexico City.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: So we called and they told us to stay where you are, we’ll go get you, so they went and got us.

BETEND: They took the family to a hotel where other refugees would be staying for a few days while the sanctuary workers made final preparations for the trip to the US border.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: And we were there. We spent Christmas there, you know, in that room. It was very sad. And then, you know, a couple of people came to get us, they put us on a plane for the first time in our lives. You know, we’re so afraid. [Portillo-Bartow laughs.] We were these people from Guatemala, you know, who never left the country but to go to El Salvador, and then we are put in this huge plane. [Portillo-Bartow laughs.]

BETEND: The plane took them North to a border city

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Agua Prieta, Black Waters.

BETEND: Where they celebrated a tense but hopeful New Year’s, 1985.

After a few days a new group of Sanctuary workers came to guide them through the last stretch of the journey which they would have to make on foot. The border to the United States was technically half a mile away, but there were still more than 100 miles to walk before they’d made it.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: It was around 11:00 at night, to cross the border…

It's called, now, the Devil’s Highway. So, that’s where we walked. And it was very painful, we had to crawl our entrance, you know, into the United States. And then we transferred hands to pastors. Protestant pastors, and a couple that were Catholic now.

BETEND: Together, the new crew set off into the Arizona desert.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: And maybe three hours into the night, it was a desert, right, and there were a lot of rocks. And I had never in my life carried one of those backpacks, you know that people carry here. They put one of those on my back, and you know, we’re jumping, you know, on rocks, and I go, and the backpack just took me back, you know, and I broke my arm three hours into the journey. They didn’t have anything but Tylenol, you know? They improvised, you know, on things. And we kept – and kept going,

BETEND: The trip was expected to take them 3-4 days. They slept only a few hours a night, waking at 5am to take advantage of any sunlight that wasn't the brutal heat of the midday sun. Their meals were the same each time: oranges, chocolate and juice.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: And during the day, there was an INS [Immigration and Naturalization Service], you know, airplane that was combing the desert. It would come this way, and then it would come this way, and go this way, and go this way, until it got to the other side. And then, it would come this way, and this way, and this way, and this way, looking, looking for people. And every time the plane, you know, is getting closer, we just would hide, you know, under bushes.

…And then when the plane was far, we would get from under then run again, you know? And it would come back again, you know, like we were rabbits.

BETEND: Soon they got the first sign they were getting close. A “Welcome to America”, in the form of the faint distant sound of cows mooing in the distance. That night, they slept for the last time under a fully star filled sky.

The first wave of the sanctuary movement began in the 1980s in response to waves of displacement caused by civil wars in both Guatemala and El Salvador.   

REBEKAH COFFMAN: In 1982, Chicago's Wellington Avenue Church in the Lakeview neighborhood became just the second church in the country to start harboring refugees from Central America who had come to the United States mostly to escape political repression and violence.

BETEND: Rebekah Coffman is the curator of Religion and Community history at the Chicago History Museum.

COFFMAN: And so these were folks that were coming as political refugees that were seeking asylum in many cases from countries that were in a state of instability due to US intervention in politics.

And so these networks of religious institutions grew, and actually here in Chicago, there were over 20 religious congregations of diverse religious identities that formed the Chicago Religious Task Force. And that became a place like a literal sanctuary or safe haven for folks that were seeking asylum at the time.

BETEND: The Chicago Religious Task Force on Central America trained volunteers, and organized speaking opportunities so refugees could tell their story to the general public.

COFFMAN: This was a national network of sites and like I said, Chicago was one of the first and earliest adopters of becoming sanctuary cities. But there were sites all over the country, West Coast, Southwest,

…and all of these cities were seeing themselves as a network kind of on a political civic level.

But then there also were these networks of religious denominations and faiths that saw themselves as, I guess, an underground, underground railroad of sorts. And so for example, in the exhibition we feature, um, guidance for how the Jewish reform movement was conceiving of themselves as sanctuary providers.

You know, and this was a denomination national guide, um, and having that kind of playbook, if that's how you wanna look at it, for how to essentially justify what was breaking the law at the time. I mean, there were federal indictments against religious and community leaders who provided sanctuary because it wasn't- it was seen as an illegal act.

(Music)

BETEND: The sanctuary workers took Adriana and her family to a convent in Tucson, Arizona where they would stay for a couple weeks.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Two weeks. Uh, uh, living in a basement in a convent.

BETEND: While they were there, they met the founders of the Sanctuary movement, Jim Corbet and John Fife.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: And that was, um, the times when, you know, sanctuary workers had been, you know, taken by the INS.

BETEND: That’s Immigration and Naturalization Service

COFFMAN: Famously in 1986, there were the sanctuary trials, which were a series of federal court cases against sanctuary leaders, in which they were federally indicted on many counts for these acts of providing sanctuary.

BETEND: Fife and Corbet would be among the people arrested and charged. In total, the Justice Department indicted 16 people on 71 counts of conspiracy and aiding people illegally entering the United States by shielding, harboring, and transporting them.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: It was right then, when all of that was happening, that they brought us in to show the government that nothing was going to stop them. Yeah. That nothing would stop them.

When we got in the room in the basement, it was just, so the room was, I mean, full of cameras from all over the world.

BETEND: To Adrianna’s surprise, the basement of the cameras was full of cameras. In that basement packed full of media, camera operators, nervous asylum seekers and nuns, Adrianna told the world her story.

PORTILLO-BARTOW’S INTERVIEWER: Okay.  Now, there’s – on the internet, there’s quite a bit about the events of your family in September of 1981.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Yeah.  Can you get me some Kleenex, please?

INTERVIEWER: Yes.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: I’m going to need it.

INTERVIEWER: Okay.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Okay.

INTERVIEWER: Just take your time.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Because it was hard for me-

INTERVIEWER: Oh, I understand, yes, ma’am.  I understand.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: - to remember, because for me, it's like I'm, I'm there. Mm-hmm. I can see mm-hmm. You know, and feel everything.

BETEND: September 11th, 1981.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Um, 1981 was, you know, was probably one of the years of the highest political upheaval in Guatemala. Mm-hmm. And at the highest level of violence.

BETEND: Adriana and her family finally fled Guatemala in 1985, but the truth is they had been waiting years for the opportunity. The events that convinced her they had to run happened 4 years earlier in 1981.

But in order to understand what happened, allow me to go back even further and explain how deeply Adriana’s life was shaped by displacement and opposition to government violence.

Before Adriana was born, her parents had fled to Guatemala from El Salvador.

Her father was a political exile, barred from ever returning because of his involvement with the leftist Guerilla forces opposing the US-backed government.

After resettling in Guatemala he opened a small funeral home.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Death is a big business in Guatemala. Mm-hmm. You know?

BETEND: As a child, Adriana remembers playing hide and seek with her brothers amongst the unused coffins.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: We were never afraid.  You know, of death. Uh, my father used to say, be afraid of the alive and not of the dead. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. And, uh, I remember my father was always armed, you know, in those years.

INTERVIEWER: It sounds like your father was afraid that the El Salvadorian government might actually try and get him in Guatemala City or Jutiapa.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. Or even not only the Salvadorian government, but the Guatemalan government.

BETEND: Adriana’s brothers followed in her father’s footsteps, joining the Guerilla fighters in the mountains. At 17 Adriana married her husband. By the age of 25, they had 4 children, all girls.

On the morning of September 10th, 1981, her father came over and picked up her two eldest daughters so they could spend the day with their grandfather. The whole family would meet up at her father’s house on the 11th for a picnic celebrating her 1-year-old nephew’s birthday.

As planned the next day, Adriana, her sister-in-law, and her other two daughters made the 3-hour bus ride to her father’s house.

PORTILLO-BARTOW:  But as soon as we got off the bus, we started noticing that there were police cars and army trucks and men and, you know, surrounding completely this maybe four blocks area, but the major concentration was around one block.

And that was the block where my father's house was. And in front of the house there were approximately 30 soldiers, um, police, uh, the members of the SWAT command, uh, men in plain clothes with walkie talkies, all armed.

BETEND: One of the officers in plain clothes asks Adriana who she is. She identifies herself as the daughter of the owner of the house they're standing in front of. He tells her to come into the house; that her father’s waiting for her inside.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: We—couldn’t understand what was happening. And my body felt just like it wasn't me. It wasn't me. You know, I, I had an out of body experience at that moment because I could see, you know, the woman there with the children, but it wasn't me. It was just, it was horrible. And um, I did realize that they were playing games with me, and I said, well, so I guess we are gonna go back to Jutiapa.

And we started walking, but maybe I had walked 10 meters when I realized what had happened. I told my sister-in-law, grab one of the children, I will grab one and we are gonna run.

Started running, running. And when they saw us running, I could hear they were charging, you know, the guns. And we were like moving towards us, but we were running, we were dragging the children, running. We were not looking, you know, behind and about a block away there was a car. And afterwards I was thinking this person probably was a compañero that was watching what was happening at my father's house.

BETEND: Compañero literally means ‘friend, or buddy’ but I suspect Adriana means that the man in the car was a member of the resistance movement her father belonged to.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Or an angel. I'm not a religious person, but who knows? You know, the thing is that the man was there and he had the doors of his car open. So we just went in there, closed the doors, and he took off as fast as he could.

BETEND: The man drives them around in circles for a while until they calm down enough to tell him where to drop them off. Nobody mentions what just happened.

That night they watched the local news camped out at her sister-in-law's house.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: We watched the news, and  the official statement given by the military was that it was like a real house, but there was no one in the house.

The house had been abandoned. Mm-hmm. By, uh, the agents of the international communism, you know, these, uh, delinquent, uh, they have all kinds of labels, you know, for us. And they said the house was empty, but I knew they were there.

BETEND: In the convent basement in Tucson, Adriana’s daughters learned, for the first time, what had happened to their sisters and grandfather.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: It was there for the first time when I said the words. My daughters were disappeared. Mm-hmm. My daughters were detained and my daughters were disappeared. And my father, and my brother.

BETEND: Six members of Adriana’s family were disappeared that day. Her two eldest daughters who were 9 and 10, her 70 year old father, along with his second wife, their 18-month old daughter, Adriana’s baby sister, and her brother’s wife who was also there that day.

COFFMAN:  Telling of what they had experienced is often called by the name testimonio, which is, as it sounds in English, testimony.

Um, but it was that first person recounting. Uh, you know, this was a personal narrative of seeing the political violence and,

You know, it was a very precarious position to be so political and forward facing. And yet the kind of call to justice and the need to bring a sense of rectification around these political injustices was seen as the reason for being so forward facing.

These weren't people just hiding out in a sanctuary, as you said, taking refuge. They, they wanted a justice corrected.

BETEND: After a few months in Arizona and Texas, Adriana and her daughters moved to a more stable long term situation at a Synagogue in Chicago. Her husband, however, didn't want to come. He decided to return to Guatemala, leaving Adriana and her daughters in America.

INTERVIEWER: Um, when you, when you were in Tucson and Fort Worth, and also in Chicago, were you afraid of the INS? Afraid that they would come and take you away?

PORTILLO-BARTOW: When I was in, in, in Tucson and Fort Worth, I was terrified.

I always lived with, you know, looking over my shoulder. Mm-hmm. Uh, I had changed my name, you know, I used to be Anamaria Garcia. I was Anamaria Garcia for five years. Mm-hmm. And I was so afraid. And when I came here, I was still Anamaria  Garcia. Mm-hmm. It was 1987. I was still Anamaria Garcia.

COFFMAN: At the same time, you do have political structures that are also trying to address what sanctuary might mean. And you know, these things are happening in tandem.

BETEND: In 1985, Mayor Harold Washington, set Chicago on the path towards sanctuary as we know it today, a city-wide effort codified in law. Washington was Chicago’s first Black mayor, a progressive who rode a wave of support from a diverse coalition, including a swell of Latine voters galvanized by the late labor organizer, Rudy Lozano, whose story we explored in Episode 1.

COFFMAN: He signed an executive order in 1985 that allowed for access to benefits for people in the city regardless of their legal status.

And so, that actually is seen as a kind of threshold of precedent for creating a safety net for undocumented people within the city.

BETEND: Mayor Washington took what has been a radical political, moral and spiritual movement and set it on track to become the actual law of the land.

COFFMAN: And so, you know, while you have religious leaders arguing this one hand, having some political, even if it's just at a local level, some political support for how people could on the ground be supported here and feel safe because they knew they could access these kinds of things, um, I think is a really important thing to keep in mind in this era.

ELENA GONZALES:  So we think about the sanctuary movement in three waves.

BETEND: Elena Gonzales is the curator of civic engagement and social justice with the Chicago History Museun.

GONZALES: There's this sort of early wave in the 1980s that coincides with, um, you know, as I was saying, a lot of violence across Latin America. And then the second wave of sanctuary is the early 2000’s.

(AUDIO - 9/11 coverage, traffic control comms up and under, then slowly fading into news coverage about US retaliation, a montage of anchors saying the word “terrorist/terror” then distant sirens, police radio chatter, as narration continues.)   

BETEND: September 11th, 2001. In the days and weeks following the attack on the World Trade Center, heightened security theater, grief and xenophobia led to increased scrutiny of immigrants.

GONZALES: Many  people are familiar with the story of Elvira Ayano, who sought sanctuary at the Adalberto United Methodist Church on Division Street in Humboldt Park

BETEND: Elena interviewed Elvira Arellano at Adelberto United Methodist Church, where she used to live. Their conversation was in Spanish, so I’ll be translating Elvira’s descriptions.

ELVIRA ARELLANO [translated]: It was after the 9/11 terrorist attacks that the federal government began raiding all airports nationwide in search of potential terrorists and in the name of national security. And this is how it was on December 10, 2002, when federal agents came to my house knocking on my door.

It was about 7:00 in the morning, more or less, and I asked who it was, and they told me it was the police.

A murder had taken place in front of the building where I lived a few days earlier.

There was a liquor store downstairs. Through the window, we could see what had happened out there. I thought it was the police trying to find out what had happened. And well, they said, “We are the police”. And that's how I opened the door.

And they asked me, "Are you Elvira Arellano?" And I said, "Yes." I was kind of surprised, what was going on? And that's when they told me that they were federal agents.

They asked me if I had guns or a permit to carry guns. And I told them no. They asked me who else was living there….

…only my son was with me. At that time, he was going to be 4 years old. He was 3 years old at the time. And they told me that I was going to be arrested, that I had to go with them.

COFFMAN: So Elvira was an immigrant who had come from Mexico to Chicago to look for work

She had a son here, Salvito, who, um, you know, was a US citizen. She was pregnant at the time of coming and he was born here.

ARELLANO [translated]: And they asked me if I had anyone to leave my child with, and I told them “No”. That I had no family to leave him with. And they told me that then they were going to hand my child over to the state so that the state would take care of him.

And I said “No. The state doesn't support my son. I work to pay for his care”.

When they came into the room, he got scared and he started crying. "Who are they? Why are they here?"

BETEND: Elvira tried to calm her son Saul by telling them that the men were people from work.

Internally she was starting to panic. She asked the officers if they could take Saul to the house of a woman named Mrs. Claudia who occasionally watched him while Elvira was working. Mrs. Claudia was a US citizen who lived a few blocks away from the apartment where Elvira and Saul had been renting a room. They agreed.

ARELLANO [translated]: We went there and the agent wanted to ask her questions and she said, "I don't have to answer anything to you." But I told the lady, "Look, they're from immigration and because I’m working at the airport, I have to go with them. Can I leave my child with you?"

I think that's like— (Spanish)

GONZALES: Yes, take as long as you want. It's very hard. (Spanish)

ARELLANO [translated]: (crying) I think about it as it is— the moment that hurts me the most.

I still remember Mrs. Claudia and I'm always very grateful to her because—I mean, I didn't even know where she was from. She was a very nice person. She always took care of my child.

She told me, "Leave him here, my dear, don't worry. We're going to wait for you here because you're coming back."

BETEND: Elvira quickly said goodbye to Saul.

ARELLANO [translated]: "Don't worry, I'm coming back, and you know that I have to work to buy your milk, to buy your yogurt and everything that you need. So don't cry, calm down." And I was trying to tell him positive things so that he wouldn't get scared and finally I left him with Mrs. Claudia.

And I went with the federal agents. That's when they took me into custody, they put me in handcuffs.

BETEND: When Elvira was booked, INS agents discovered she had been detained once before trying to cross the border back in 1997. This would complicate her case and almost certainly result in her being deported.

ARELLANO [translated]: In the detention center— it said that you could make calls, you had the right to make a call. So, I called my sister-in-law, my brother's wife, and said, "Don't ask me questions, I'm just calling you to tell you that I was detained by immigration. The boy and I are fine," and I hung up.

BETEND: Elvira’s Family is freaking out, they know she’s detained but they don’t know Saul is safe with Mrs. Claudia.

The next day Elvira found out that instead of being deported immediately, she was being charged with using a fake social security number in a federal building and would be released until her court date.

Once she was out, Elvira went to Mrs. Claudia to pick up Saul.

ARELLANO [translated]: And I always remember, because when I went to drop off my child, she told me, "We're going to wait for you here because you're going to come back for your child." There are such good people in this life!

I didn't really imagine the big trouble I was in because they were charging me with federal charges, and I could go to prison for six months to three years in federal prison for that crime.

(AUDIO FROM PRESS CONFERENCE: I am single mom. My son, he is citizen. I am not terrorist, I am not criminal. I am mom. He is my son.)

BETEND: An organization called the coalition of immigrants and refugees got in touch and helped Elvira host a press conference to spread word about her situation. There she met a number of religious leaders associated with the sanctuary movement including the pastor of Adelberto Methodist, Emma Lozano, the sister of Labor organizer Rudy Lozano.

By the day of the trial Elvira had amassed a small collection of supporters, including legal advocates and a few people in the Mexican consulate. She showed up to trial with a handful of letters vouching for her character as a hard working single mother, but the judge didn’t want to hear it.

ARELLANO [translated]: The judge started telling me, "You're a person who doesn't respect the laws, you only came here to disrespect our laws. You are not a woman with respect. I don't know why your country's government is helping you."

“because if they knew you, they wouldn't have given you a letter because you're a disrespectful person who breaks the laws of our country.

She just saw that I came to this country undocumented, that I was working here. But I didn't steal, I didn't kill anybody, I was a good mom…And the federal judge treated me very badly, very badly.

So, I said, well, if they're going to deport me, then they're going to deport me with a reason, because now, I'm not going to leave and now, yes, I'm going to fight for myself so that I am respected as a human being, as a worker, and it is for that reason that I decided to fight.

I'm going to fight so that my son can have a better life here in his country and so that he's not a second-class citizen.

And when my time for deportation came, I resisted and spoke to my pastor and I told him, "I remember the sanctuary movement of the eighties, when Salvadorans and Central Americans were coming to the United States to seek refuge. And that many churches opened sanctuary for them."

So, I talked to my pastor, and I told him, “Why wouldn't the church be a sanctuary for me, so that I wouldn't be deported?” I thought that it’d be something like, I go to the church and stay there.

But we never imagined how big it was going to be. I didn't have a vision that, oh, this whole street is going to be filled with media vans, or this church is going to be filled with reporters, or the church is going to become a TV studio for interviews for major shows. Not really, we didn't know what was going to happen. Instead of reporting for immigration, I came to my church and my pastor declared the church a sanctuary for me.

It was a global bombshell that a woman dared to take sanctuary.

COFFMAN: And her story really did become the ignition for this kind of second wave, um, national attention.

In Elvira's case, what was distinct, um, she really argued that she was an economic refugee. So, you know, the political instability, the place that the US had intervened provided such, um, limited access to the resources.

Folks on the ground in countries like Mexico had to support their family, that she had no choice but to come here and to work and to support her family by sending money back.

BETEND: The neighborhood rallied around them, some even physically guarding the entrance of the church. From her window on the 2nd floor, Elvira could see the Puerto Rican flag waving where someone had planted it in the street below - watching it wave proudly below made her feel less alone and filled her with a sense of comfort.

ARELLANO [translated]: While I was up there, on the second floor where I slept, I saw the Puerto Rican flag waving down here the first day I took sanctuary. The second day, the third day, a week went by, and I would see the Puerto Rican flag so I asked them, "Where did you plant the flag, the flagpole?"

And they said, "No, they didn't plant it anywhere. A person is holding the Puerto Rican flag". I was stunned— what? because the flag was there all day and night. All day and at night. I was like, "But how?"  And they said, "Yes, Puerto Rican youth and Puerto Rican adults are supporting you so that someone is always there with the flag as a sign of solidarity and that we Puerto Ricans are going to defend you."

(Music)

BETEND: Neither national media attention nor the public’s sympathy for Elvira’s story were enough to stop her getting deported. In 2007 she was arrested while traveling at a speaking opportunity in California and deported to Mexico.

Interviewer: So, you were born in the US. You’re an American citizen, but after your mom was deported to Mexico, you were eight years old, and you went there to be with her. What was that experience like?

Elvira’s Son: Uh, it was a hard experience because I was living in the US and I had to change really like a lot, because I had to talk Spanish, I had to read Spanish, I had to write Spanish, and that was difficult for me, but I had-

BETEND: They were both eventually able to return to Chicago, where she’s currently working through the legal process as of 2025.

In Adriana’s case, the Sanctuary movement is also how she met her 2nd husband.

Jeff Bartow was a Sanctuary worker in Texas who played a direct role in connecting Adriana to the Synagogue in Chicago. Afterwards, they stayed in touch and in 1987 made plans to tie the knot.

PORTILLO-BARTOW:  People think that when you marry a person from the United States as a citizen, you automatically become a citizen. It's not. Right. So I had to go, we had to live for three years together, and then I had to go back to Guatemala because I came here illegally.

Mm-hmm. I had to go back and ask for forgiveness for having entered illegally. And only after I asked for forgiveness, they were gonna give me a visa.

BETEND: She reached out to multiple embassies and consulates, explaining the danger returning exposed her to and asking for an exemption.

PORTILLO-BARTOW:  And I got a fax from each of these places telling me that they were sorry, but that there is democracy in Guatemala and that I should not be afraid of going back. Guatemala is a newly, you know, blah, blah, blah, democracy. So there is no reason for you not to go back.

And they gave us the date, said you are being expected at the US Embassy in Guatemala on September 11th, 1989. Oh, September 11th.

INTERVIEWER: September 11th, the same day that your family disappeared.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: The same day, yes. I thought this, they knew that was the day. Mm-hmm. And they did it intentionally.

Sent me back and interviewed me on that exact date. It wasn’t you know, a chance. So we had to go.

When we got there on the 10th, I found out that the previous night my former brother-in-law had been killed, had been kidnapped from his house. And killed. And his body had appeared that morning.

The morning I arrived. In the paper, this is the way I learned about Carlos. I learned that a chain of bombs had gone off at the hotel we were staying. Mm-hmm. Which was the Camino Real, where, you know, it's, is maybe one of the, if not the most expensive hotel, you know, in the state, but it would stay there because that gave me security, safety.

And people from the synagogue came with me. Uh, I wasn't going along with Jeff and no. So that happens, you know, they said a chain of bombs went off at the Camino Real one in the lobby and, you know, two or three outside. And while we were there, we always saw that there were men with walkie talkies.

You know, on the floor where we were. And we were so terrified that we would, you know, and the other people had another room. So they would come to our room and we would push all the furniture in front the door. Because we were afraid they were gonna come. To get us. And uh, when we left the hotel, there was always a red car behind us.

Following us wherever we went. And, uh, when we went to the embassy, there was a long, long line, but the officer already knew that I was arriving, right?

And so we didn't have to wait. We just went inside and he himself told us he had never heard of a story like mine or a situation like mine. And, um, so he gave us the visa. It didn't last more like 15 minutes to get the visa. It was just like this. Gave us the visa. And from the embassy we went directly to the airport.

Signed the, the forgiveness, you know, form and all of that. And I got the visa and we left.

(Music)

BETEND: The figures involved with the sanctuary movement through its first two waves considered their actions morally justified civil disobedience, even their religious duty, but it’s important to keep in mind, in the eyes of the federal government, what they were doing was unambiguously illegal. Which raises the question, why did it work?

In an essay which we’ve borrowed extensively from this episode, former Chicago History Museum intern Megha Khemka writes, “The protection that a sanctuary church offers is entirely social, based on the reluctance of any authority to order a raid on a religious building.”

GONZALES: Yeah. So much of our, so much of our social experience is just a compact, it's an agreement. Right? And I think we're seeing that right now as, uh, laws are being tested and broken. We're seeing how much of the system that we rely on is just a handshake.

BETEND:  This might be a dumb question in terms of the answer being obvious, but is part of the reason that we don't see the same thing happening now because states and cities on the whole have passed sanctuary ordinances, like in the case of Illinois and Chicago that people don't need to physically be in a church anymore? Is that why this movement, the third wave, sort of looks different than the second wave?

COFFMAN: I feel like there's a “yes and” answer.

BETEND: If the first and second waves of the sanctuary movement were most famous for the act of physically taking refuge in a church, I thought, the defining feature of the period we’re living through as this is written in 2025, would be about city and state protections, building up to the point that all of Chicago was a metaphorical church, making seeking sanctuary unnecessary. Rebekah pretty quickly made me realize how silly that idea was, even if she was too polite to say so.

COFFMAN: I would agree, you know, having political precedent with Harold Washington, but later precedents by Mayor Emmanuel, that codify undocumented rights in the city is certainly an element within that.  I equally think the movement of undocumented immigrants across the country enforced migration patterns by, let's say conservative state governments to sanctuary cities like Chicago is an interesting counterpoint to that. Right? There is a politicization by the government on purpose of bringing attention to these movements and wanting them to be in public spaces and doing so in a way where they don't know what shelter or infrastructure there is for folks on the other end.

In recent memory, 2022, 2023, buses of folks coming to Chicago, at a time that was warm and there was no social infrastructure for where they go when it's cold. Right?

What I call, like, forced internal deportation.

Um, and that's a forced politicization for sure.

BETEND: The defining feature of the 3rd wave of sanctuary is the targeting of sanctuary cities, because they are sanctuary cities.  

[Texas Gov Sends migrants to Chicago ]

News Broadcast Reporter: Hey good morning. Now that group of migrants arrived around 7:30 last night and they were brought here to the Salvation Army Freedom Center. Well some of them-

BETEND: In Aug 2022 buses of asylum seekers began showing up in downtown Chicago in an intentional effort to overwhelm the resources of Sanctuary cities, orchestrated by the Governor of Texas, Greg Abbott. The same man who authorized sending Texas’s National Guard to Chicago.

Reporter: Governor Abbott made it known about his plan to charter buses to transport undocumented individuals from Texas to Washington D.C. He then added New York city and then Chicago to the list of cities after claiming Texas is overwhelmed…

[Making a statement ]

COFFMAN: You know, people didn't ask to leave Texas, they were forced to leave Texas, that kinda thing. Right? Um, I don't know if internal deportation is used often, but that's I think, it is accurate.

[Migrants arrive ]

(News Broadcast) Reporter 2: People from Texas are waking up here in Chicago

We know those migrants arrived around 7:45 last night at Union Station…In a tweet Abbott said Texas will continue busing migrants to sanctuary cities.

We caught up with Mayor Lori Lightfoot last night-

COFFMAN: So people are outside, you know, they are sleeping outside. Police stations, fire stations, Not just in civic service centers or places provided by the city, and in fact there was a lot of reporting around the inadequacy of city provided shelters.

Um, you know, and some really horrific things around health and safety for people that were staying there. And you do have a lot of reports of religious communities, again, coming together to fill in those gaps and to provide services that the government wasn't able to bring together. And I, I know in my local community, there were calls for winter jackets and blankets and everything almost immediately because people were like, what are folks gonna do?

It's winter here.

Tom Homan (These cities are on notice): The sanctuary cities can sit by and watch their communities get ravaged by illegal aliens. The Tr*mp administration is not going to stand for that. If they don’t do it, we will do it for them. You are going to see a lot of things happen in the next few months that people should expect, many don’t but watch what comes in their future.

[Tr*mp admin sues Chicago ]

The Department of Justice is now suing the city Chicago as well as the state of Illinois, they’re arguing that the leaders, they’re literally obstructing ICE from doing their job. Now, this happened on Attorney General Pam Bondi’s first day in office, signaling that it’s a really big priority for her leadership.

BETEND: Has it crossed your mind that by the time the exhibit opens there will be National Guard in the street?

GONZALES: Oh my god, yes absolutely it is.

BETEND: Most recently, the President of the United States deployed the Texas National Guard to Chicago under the guise of protecting ICE agents and stopping crime.

GONZALES: Illegal has not stopped him up to this point and I would not be surprised to see the National Guard in Chicago. And I view that as a kind of civil war.

(News Excerpt: They’re picking sanctuary cities on purpose. Tom Homan, who Von Hillard talked to there, has always really had a thorn in his side. The thorn in his side is sanctuary cities.)

GONZALES: Yeah. I think that’s a real concern that I have

BETEND: While a court order has paused guard deployment, at least as of this recording, September saw the roll out of a massive ICE surge, ominously titled Operation Midway Blitz. In the lead up to the operation, ICE agents in California detained a U.S. Citizen. Far from the first. A warning that the following audio is distressing.

[ICE agents detain two men]

Citizen: Hold up

Agent: Abre la puerta (open the door)

Citizen: Hold up, hold up,

Agent: Hold up nothing. What?

Citizen: You guys have no right to do that!

Agent: We don’t have rights to do that?

Citizen: No. You can’t grab me like that. You can’t grab me like that.

(Commotion)

Citizen: What are yall doing bro? Hey! Hey Gaby [to his companion who is being detained], no resistas [don’t resist]. Yeah, no resistas. What am I doing?

(Agents tase the other man.)

Citizen: Hey! Hey! Hey!

Agent: Get on the ground

Citizen: Alright bro. You can’t be doing that alpha male-

Agent: Get on the ground!

Citizen: I got rights to talk bro-

Agent: You’ve got no rights here

Citizen: I do!

Agent: You’re an illegal. Get up!

Citizen: I was born and raised over here!

BETEND: After both men were in custody the camera captured the seemingly unaware agents laughing about the arrest.

[ICE agents talking to each other unaware]

Agent 2: “Once she got that proper spurt on him he was gone.

Agent 1: “You’re funny, bro”

(Laughter)

Agent 2: “They’re starting to resist more.”

Agent 1: “We’re going to end up shooting some of them.”

BETEND: The other agent responds, “We’re going to end up shooting some of them.”

(Villegas Gonzales shooting: Breaking News out of Chicago now, a deadly shooting involving an ICE officer. Homeland Security officials say it happened this morning after officers pulled over a car allegedly being driven by an undocumented immigrant. They said that the driver stopped, but then-)

(Music)

BETEND: I can’t stress enough how dangerous and dystopian this has all felt. The level of pure confusion and fear, which is, of course, the point. Expanding on a list originally published by Block Club Chicago, since the operation began, federal agents in and around Chicago have shot at least two people, killing one, repeatedly tear gassed protesters and first responders, shot rubber bullets at protestors, detained U.S. citizens, including children, handcuffed a Chicago alderperson in the hospital, smokebombed and teargassed people in Logan Square, Albany Park, and East Side, fired a chemical weapon at a TV reporter, detained a journalist and repeatedly rubber balled a priest in the head, among other incidents.

COFFMAN: I think there is something to think about. What the relationship between government and social organizations and perhaps this idea that there was a social decorum or a social norm during the 1980s that perhaps we feel like is wearing thin now.

And what are the reasons, or the political tensions around that? But I do think in the 1980s religious organizations did hold a kind of social moral compass in society that people respected and seemingly, even the government respected enough to say that as a threshold we won't cross. So even if it is a social norm, not even a political, um, or legal boundary, you know, that that is something that, um, was respected at the time. It is interesting to see, like I said, that wearing thin now.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: I was so afraid at the beginning. That when I heard an ambulance, I would panic.

If I hear the police car, or saw a police car, I would panic. If I saw a soldier, I would panic. Uh, once with my daughters and I, we were on the train and we saw a group of men, uh, with military pants and black, uh, boots, and these, you know, white shirts with these red, you know, things. And I thought they, I even said aloud, “They found us! They found us. Let's get out.” And we got out of the train because the, I remember walking, like, they were walking toward us and we, you know, got out of the train. I have no idea where we were. We just got out and it was maybe around seven. And, you know, we got out, started walking. It's a very, very dangerous area in the northwest side.

But later I found out that they were the Guardian Angels.

INTERVIEWER: Oh, yes. Wow.

PORTILLO-BARTOW: But to me, to me, they were the men that were coming to get me. Oh, I'm not as afraid as before, you know? But I am still afraid. Sometimes I'm still afraid.

INTERVIEWER: What do you think is the, the biggest single positive thing to come out of the sanctuary movement and your activism Through the 1980s and early nineties while the sanctuary movement was still active?

PORTILLO-BARTOW: I think that with the sanctuary movement, politically speaking, is to bring attention to what was going on. In El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras. Here in the United States, I think it probably educated people, you know. Um, opened the minds of a lot of people.

Mm-hmm. You know, probably conservative people. I think the movement grew huge because, uh, people could see that we were human beings like everybody.You know, and that we were not a threat, you know, to them. As individuals, the sanctuary movement saved our lives, you know?

Many, many lives.

(Music)

PORTILLO-BARTOW: Also, I think this is, for me, this is the most important. The sanctuary movement taught me, and I am sure most of the people who were in sanctuary, that we cannot generalize when we say, you know, “those gringos, you know, all of them are the same. They are oppressors. They come to, you know, steal our resources. They are wealthy because of our resources, and we are poor, and then they don't want us here. While, they have, you know, occupied our countries.” We make those generalizations. I made those generalizations.

And, uh, now, you know, I, I learned through the Sanctuary movement that there is a big, big sector of the US population that disagrees completely with the foreign policy of the government of the United States. And it's not only that they disagree, that they have been capable of doing things. They put themselves in danger to change that policy. And that once they make that commitment, they will never abandon that commitment.

And they're angry. They're angry because of all the injustice this country has done. And I have great respect for that sector of the people of the United States.

In a way, that large sector of the people of the United States are kind of protecting our lives and the lives of the people we left behind.

You know, they gave me back the trust that I had lost in other human beings. 'Cause, uh, after what happened, you know what trust can you feel for anyone?

Who can you trust? I didn't even trust myself. I didn't even trust myself. You know, I totally lost that trust.

And the sanctuary movement, they gave me back that trust. They taught me to trust again.

(Music)

BETEND: One final thought for this episode:

I’m recording this in the middle of Midway Blitz, and I can’t help but notice the weird static in the air in October of 2025. I also find myself thankful for having this project to put myself into.

A wise man once said, “When the chips are down, write a corrido”, right?

So here is one final little story about an object. While the Tr*mp administration’s targeting of undocumented communities should be front and center, they’re unraveling not just norms but also cultural institutions, including museums.

TR*MP [on the Smithsonian]: Well we want the museums to treat our country fairly, we want them to talk about the history of our country in a fair manner, not in a woke manner, or in a racist manner.

BETEND: In a post on August 19th, Tr*mp accused the Smithsonian Institution of being "Out of control" for focusing on negative aspects of American history, including how bad Slavery was, while ignoring, quote, "Success, ... Brightness, ... [and] the Future". He also called U.S. museums "the last remaining segment of 'WOKE'".

That same month, the White House formally informed the Smithsonian that a systematic review would begin, with the goal of removing "divisive or partisan narratives".

Tr*mp also stated on Truth Social that he had instructed his attorneys to begin the "exact same process" with other museums.

The truth is that CHM has not been spared.

The creation of the Aquí en Chicago Exhibition was funded, in part, by 4 sources of federal dollars. In the spring of 2025, about 6 months before the exhibition was set to open, Elena and her team found out that all four would be Terminated.

GONZALES: It immediately put me in mind of the Chicago History Museum's costume collection, which is one of the most well-known and well-respected costume collections in the country.

And in particular, the black velvet suit belonging to George Washington that is in our collection and is in the process of restoration as we speak. It is part of a grant that the History Museum received in advance of the 250th celebration of the United States. And it's interesting to me that  the conservation of these kind of classic American items, like the suit that George Washington is wearing on the dollar bill, is the only one of our federal grants that was not affected during the grant terminations over the spring.

BETEND: Oh wow. That’s really fascinating.

GONZALES: I think it's really interesting that it's the suit on the dollar bill, right? Like that's, that's quintessentially United Statesian

BETEND: It's important not to mistake this as an attempt to defund history or something like that. The Tr*mp admin doesn't want to destroy museums, they want to control which stories museums tell.

Next time on Building Aquí

(Music)

BETEND: These are just some of the stories contained in the Aquí en Chicago exhibition. We hope you’ll visit and explore the many treasures Elena and her team have collected in person.

Next Episode, we’ll explore how Chicago, this Midwestern city, far away from all of the borders, became the 2nd largest population of Latine people in the country.

How they helped build it into the economic engine it became.

And how the Tr*mp administration’s immigration policy, while shocking in its cruelty and disregard for established norms, isn’t altogether new, but a more intense version of some of the more shameful periods in our country’s history.

BUILDING AQUÍ IS CO-CREATED BY Elena Gonzales and Jesse Betend

This episode is written by Jesse Betend, based on the interview “Chicago Cold War: Adriana Portillo Bartow” By Peter Alter, and Elvira Arellano by Elena Gonzales

With additional editing by Elena Gonzales, Paulina Budzioch, Sheila Solomon, Cindy Paulauskas, and Joe DeCeault (pr. De-SO)

The show is produced by Jesse Betend and Rob Lafrenze.

A thank you to Thema McDonald, without whom this podcast would not exist.

These stories and the Aquí en Chicago Exhibition would not exist without Elena’s curatorial colleagues, Jojo Galván Mora, Digital Humanities Fellow and Rebekah Coffman, Curator of Religion and Community History as well as the work of 43 advisors, 26 storytellers, 29 interns, 10 volunteers, and of course the students of IJLA

I’m Jesse Betend. Thank you for listening

See you next time for the final episode of The Missing Exhibition: Building Aquí

Episode 3: We Came Here to Work

What does it mean to serve a country that doesn’t always serve you back?

We trace the life of Frank Corona—a Vietnam War veteran and the first Latino firefighter hired by the Chicago Fire Department—whose story embodies both sacrifice and endurance. Corona agreed to put his life on the line overseas and at home, navigating racism from fellow soldiers and firefighters while remaining committed to public service.

CHM_Aqui_PodcastGraphic_Episode3_1400x1400_2

Episode 4: Battle Queen

When Reyna Ortiz decided to change her name, she discovered she would need to change society first.

In the final episode of Building Aquí, we follow Reyna Ortiz’s quest to change not just her name, but the state law that prevented her from doing so. Along the way, we meet fellow “Battle Queen” Tania Còrdova—an immigrant and trans activist who helped push lawmakers to confront the issue, even engaging skeptical and often openly transphobic voters in rural parts of Illinois.

CHM_Aqui_Podcast_Eps4_1400x1400_Final_1

BONUS EPISODE: Interview with Journalist & Author Gary Rivlin

“Write about the tortilla factories and you’re dead.” That was the warning journalist Gary Rivlin received just days after publishing an investigation into the murder of Rudy Lozano.

This bonus episode presents the full interview with Gary Rivlin, released in its entirety. Rivlin reflects on the intimidation he faced and the questions law enforcement never answered.

CASA Chicano Organization
Translate »